Edgartown vs Nantucket
Across the six headline livability metrics (schools, safety, walkability, biking, affordability, and commute), Nantucket edges Edgartown 2 to 1 with 3 ties. Median homes in Edgartown run roughly $1.19M cheaper than in Nantucket, about 39% less. Edgartown is about 10 minutes closer to Boston by car at peak.
The two towns at a glance
Edgartown
Nantucket
Head-to-head: every metric
| Edgartown | Nantucket | |
|---|---|---|
| Headline | ||
| Livability index | 61 | 65 ✦ |
| Economics | ||
| Median home | $1.84M | $3.03M ✦ |
| Household income | $125k | $140k ✦ |
| Price ÷ income | 14.7× | 21.7× |
| Tax burden | 50 | 52 ✦ |
| Schools & Safety | ||
| Schools | 78 | 78 |
| Safety | 92 ✦ | 88 |
| Getting around | ||
| Commute to Boston | 130 min | 140 min |
| Walkability | 52 | 55 ✦ |
| Transit | 10 | 25 ✦ |
| Biking | 45 | 60 ✦ |
| Lifestyle | ||
| Dining | 70 | 78 ✦ |
| Nightlife | 35 | 42 ✦ |
| Arts & culture | 50 | 58 ✦ |
| Green space | 50 | 60 ✦ |
| Community | ||
| Diversity | 22 | 25 ✦ |
| Climate | 62 | 62 |
| 5-yr trend | 65 | 68 ✦ |
Clay = wins this metric. Direction matters: lower median home and shorter commute are better; everything else, higher is better.
Compare on your terms
These winners are based on a neutral, equal weighting of every metric. Your priorities are not neutral. Open Edgartown vs Nantucket in the interactive atlas to tune schools, walkability, affordability, commute, and seven more dimensions, and watch the verdict change.
Stuck between Edgartown and Nantucket?
I'm Gary Fikes, a licensed real estate agent at MP Signature Realty and the curator of this site. I've walked both towns. Tell me what matters most and I'll give you a straight answer within 1 business day. No auto-dialer, no spam, no resale.
About this comparison
Bay State Atlas ranks 194 Massachusetts towns using public data (Census ACS, MA DESE schools, Walk Score, MA Department of Revenue tax data, and the FBI UCR safety index) normalized to 0–100. Every weight is editable. This page is a static, indexable snapshot. The live tool is faster and lets you customize what counts.